Fighting for Canada
is a study of seven battles fought either to defend Canada or by Canadian
soldiers overseas. The work of six professional historians (four of
them combat arms officers), Fighting for Canada emphasizes
the tactical level of war -- the sharp end of the business where soldiers
kill and are killed, and where personal leadership, training and experience
are of paramount importance. The actions included are Ticonderoga,
1758; Queenston Heights, 1812; Ridgeway, 1866; Leliefontein,
1900; Moreuil Wood, 1918; Le Mesnil-Patry (Normandy)
1944; and the Kapelsche Veer, 1945. Edited and with an
introduction by Donald E. Graves, Fighting for Canada will
appeal to any reader interested in military history, the nature of
combat and the meaning of courage.
Excerpt from
Chapter 7,
"If only we had the wisdom of our generals:"
The Kapelsche Veer, 26-31 January 1945, by Donald E. Graves
copyright
©2000 by Donald E. Graves and must not be reproduced without the author's
permission.
In January 1945,
following abortive attacks by the 1st Polish Armoured Division and
the Royal Marine Commandos, the 10th Canadian Infantry Brigade was
given the task of eliminating a German stronghold on the Kapelsche
Veer, a low boggy island on the south bank of the Maas River in Holland.
Staff officers came up with an elaborate plan for Operation ELEAPHANT
that called for the use of a massive smoke screen to cover the initial
assault of the Lincoln and Welland Regiment, the unit chosen for the
attack. Three companies of the Lincs (A, B and C) would move along
the dykes that composed the Veer while, at the same time, a special
canoe assault force would actually paddle down the river into the
heart of the German defences. It was a risky plan but orders were
orders ......
0peration ELEPHANT got under way at 7.15 A.M. on Friday, 26
January 1945. Ninety minutes before, "in the half-light of the setting
moon and the rising sun," the first smoke rounds came down as the
artillery started to build up a diversionary screen across the Maas
to confuse the defenders. The main screen on the island was laid
just before the attack began and it was thickened by smoke pots
and artificial smoke generators dispersed around the island in locations
thought most likely to blanket the defences. Within a few minutes,
one onlooker reported, the entire area "was clouded out and there
was nothing we could see." The engineers held their breath as the
first vehicle, a half track loaded with smoke containers, crossed
the "Mad Whore's Dream." It "hit the steep ramp at about 30 MPH
and came down with a tremendous crash," but as "nothing gave way,"
the relieved sappers exhaled and declared their rickety span to
be structurally sound. Under the cover of billowing thick, oily
grey chemical smoke, the men of the three Lincoln and Welland assault
companies clambered into white-painted Buffalo LVTs (Landing Vehicles,
Tracked) and crossed to the island. To a watching war correspondent,
"it was a ghost-like sight as the soldiers set out in these amphibious
tank-like vehicles."

PzKpfw IV Ausf.
J, copyright © Christopher Johnson
The right hand attack went in first. At 7.25 A.M. Major James
Dandy's C Company of the Lincoln and Welland Regiment, debussing
from their Buffalos, prepared to move along the dyke to link up
with Major Owen Lambert's A Company, which crossed about a mile
and a half to the west. Dandy quickly discovered that he had a major
problem - his Wasp carriers, intended to neutralize the German defensive
positions, were unable to climb the slippery sides of the south
dyke because of the weight of their flamethrowing equipment. This
problem would have been discovered earlier and a solution likely
found if the Lincoln and Welland Regiment had been given enough
time to make a proper reconnaissance of the area over which they
had to advance but, as their historian notes, the unit had only
taken over positions on the island from the Poles the day before
the attack began. As Dandy recalled, the Wasps would
take a run at the thing and the tracks would
just spin. I figured if I could get one up, I could tow the others
up. I thought maybe I can blow that damn tank off [the back of
the carrier] with hand grenades. I backed the carrier up by this
canal, pulled the pin out of the hand grenade, and put it near
the brackets and walked away. And it just dented the metal. So
I couldn't get the carriers up.
Leaving the useless vehicles behind, Dandy's men advanced west
along the dyke top towards Lambert's A Company.
Lambert's men, transported with two Wasps to the Veer by amphibious
vehicles, had lost one carrier crossing the Oude Maasje. The second
vehicle made it safely but coulddt climb onto the dyke. At that
moment A Company came under accurate and heavy enemy mortar fire
from the north bank but Lambert decided to press on and his men,
choking in the harsh acrid fumes of the chemical smoke, moved west
along the dyke top toward the two houses code-named GRAPES and RASPBERRY.
The sixty-man canoe party reached the island by way of the "Mad
Whore's Dream." When they attempted to launch their craft into the
main river channel, however, they discovered that there was an inch
of ice on the surface - a fact that had been reported at 5 A.M.
by the Algonquin Regiment, who were monitoring river conditions.
The party was forced to haul their canoes over this crust of ice
to reach open water and by the time they embarked and moved downstream
both the men and their weapons were soaked.
Unfortunately, the canoeists' troubles were just beginning.
The ice along the north bank of the island forced them to move farther
out into the main channel of the Maas where the smoke was less thick,
and as they paddled their fragile craft furiously toward the harbour
they came under accurate fire from the north bank of the river.
Matters were not helped when the wind began to shift, thinning out
their smoke cover even more. Lieutenant Lloyd Grose of the Argylls,
whose platoon was on the eastern spit of the Veer to hold a "firm
base" for the sappers at the bridge, watched horrified through windows
in the smoke screen as the men in the canoes were "picked off by
the machine guns from the far side of the river." Several of the
craft were sunk and the party was forced to land on the north side
of the Veer near where Lambert's A Company had reached the island.
They were now about halfway to their objective but only about fifteen
were still on their feet. As soon as they moved on top of the dyke,
they came under heavy fire from German machine guns firing along
fixed lines through the smoke. When they tried to return this fire,
the canoeists discovered that their weapons, thoroughly soaked during
their short but perilous voyage, were frozen solid and would not
work. The survivors withdrew to the mainland.
Lambert meanwhile had advanced toward the centre of the German
position. His company was within thirty yards of GRAPES when the
Germans opened up with every weapon they could bring to bear. The
volume of fire brought his advance to a standstilll five of the
six officers in his company being killed or wounded. Lambert was
last seen walking up the dyke by himself, swearing and cursing "a
blue streak," until he disappeared in the smoke." He did not return.
Attempts to flush out the defenders with the portable flamethrowers
proved useless as most of the men carrying them were cut down as
soon as they started their flames. One Lincs officer commented on
the difficulties of these weapons:
I had lifebuoy flamethrowers. I think I had
ten. Lost every goddamn man; every one of them was killed. You
can imagine what it was like. I think they weighed about 60 pounds.
He's got army boots on with metal cleats on the heels filled with
snow. He's walking on an angle and carrying the goddamned thing;
trying to manoeuvre is almost impossible. And the minute they
shot any flames they were a target and every one of them got it.
I always felt really badly about that [because] we asked for volunteers.
I diddt want to take them in the first place, but they felt that's
what we had to have so we took them. And I never used them again.
By 9.45 A.M. the survivors of Lambert's A Company had fallen
back and were beginning to dig in along the dyke, a few hundred
yards short of the objective. At that moment the Germans brought
down a heavy and accurate mortar barrage from the north bank of
the river and then counterattacked, driving the remnants of the
company back on Dandy's C Company coming behind them. Dandy tried
to rally A Company and resume the advance but this movement became
confused when he and all his C Company officers became casualties.
The attack on the right was over and the remnants of Dandy and
Lambert's men were withdrawn through Grose's Argyll platoon at the
bridging site, a movement that caused Grose some problems:
They had lost their weapons and so on, and
they started to congregate around our platoon, where we were on
the dikes. And I said "Move on or you'll draw fire." So the next
thing I knew, we were getting mortar fire ourselves 'cause they
were observed from the far shore when they had stopped.
In contrast, progress on the left, or western, side of the island
was initially good. Major Ed Brady's B Company of the Lincs crossed
to the island in Buffalos and then moved steadily east along the
dyke toward RASPBERRY, the westernmost of the two houses. Then they
ran into trouble - as Corporal Howard Loughlin remembered: "You
couldn't see in front of you and the phosphorus [smoke] got into
your lungs," the German slit trenches " were all covered with snow"
and "you couldn't tell where their fire was coming from" and "talk
about cold." "All of a sudden," Loughlin continued,
this guy yelled and here these grenades coming
over the dyke. Where are you going to go in seven seconds? That
was the third grenade that I had thrown at me, and the other two
didn't go off... but this one sure as hell did. I just covered
my head up ... I waited for the damn thing to go off, it seemed
like an eternity. It just felt like somebody had punched me ...
And then I went to stand up and I couldn't.
Brady's company tried to push forward but, as he remembered
it, "they opened up on us both with mortars and machine guns" and
he "started losing men hand over fist."" With his soldiers "going
down like ten pins," and realizing that he "would just lose more
and more men," Brady decided to pull back and dig in at the junction
of the main dyke and a smaller dyke that ran north from his crossing
spot. The Germans immediately began to infiltrate around his position
using the dykes as cover, snipers became active, and his situation
was very shaky."
By noon it was obvious that the assault on the Kapelsche Veer
was a total failure. So much for the element of surprise. ......
What Reviewers say
about Fighting for Canada
5-star *****
[The individual studies] are done with a very high degree of scholarship,
detail, and are profusely illustrated with both pictures/photographs
and maps. The characterization of the key personnel involved are fascinating.
Soldiers and commanders seldom chronicled are brought into focus;
tales of uncommon valor told for the first time in a history available
to all and sundry; interesting anecdotes and comments (the best one
in my opinion describing a pet monkey as either a "staff officer,
or perhaps war correspondent" to be particularly hilarious and telling).
There are linkages between the chapters to bring the reader into focus
with the next telling of the tale, and the book boils down into one
of the best chronicles of men at war published in a very long while.
Don Graves, a proven military historian, has now shown himself to
be an editor of particularly keen insight. ..... This book is an important
addition to literature on fighting men in general, Canadians in particular,
and has a little bit for enthusiasts of all periods ...... This book
is highly recommended. In short, it is superb.
D.C. Kiley, Amazon.com Reviews, 20 April
2002
"In the field of military history, Donald Graves is well known
and respected as a researcher, writer, and editor. In the seven battles
described in Fighting for Canada, he emphasizes "the sharp
end, where soldiers kill and are killed, and where personal leadership,
training, weapons and experience are of paramount importance." ......
After each account, certain lessons are suggested. Those most frequently
mentioned are the importance of intelligence leadership, thorough
training, planning, knowledge of the terrain and the enemy's dispositions,
and trust among soldiers. ....... Generously supported with maps,
illustrations, a bibliography and nine appendices, Fighting for
Canada belongs on the shelf of anyone with an interest in military
history."
Wesley B. Turner, Canadian Book Review Annual
2000
"Over the past twenty years, ... military history has increasingly
given attention to the experiences of non-combatants and of ordinary
soldiers, and to the lessons of warfare, rather than simply dealing
with battles and military heroes. Such a change makes this history
more interesting and meaningful and one of the main contributors to
the trend has been the editor of Fighting for Canada. ......
He does not view the future optimistically because he warns, as armed
conflict continues to occur across the world, 'Canadian soldiers,
while praying for peace, must prepare for war.' ..... Anyone with
an interest in Canadian history should find this book fascinating
and it is a must for any student of military history."
Wesley Turner, Downtowner, March 2001
"What a delight this book is! ...... Graves's introduction is an
excellent primer on the nature of the tactical fight -- 'the real
business of war.' ...... each chapter provides detailed and scholarly
analysis of the battle in question. In many cases the historical record
is corrected as authors make good use of a wide variety of primary
and secondary sources. In other cases, the authors are breaking new
ground, examining in detail minor tactical engagements that have long
been ignored and forgotten. ...... This is military history as it
should be written: sound in reasoning, precise in detail and firmly
placed within the relevant political, military and social contexts.
It incorporates the testimony of private and general and does not
shirk, where necessary, from passing judgement or according praise.
It causes one to think, and think again, on the military history of
our nation -- and I can think of no higher praise."
Michael Cessford, Canadian Military Journal,
Autumn 2000
"This tour through triumph and tragedy, when the Canadian was a fighting
soldier and not a semi-toothless United Nations' peacekeeper, bound
by "rules of engagement" is an excellent read."
Ron Lowman, Toronto Daily Star, 5 November
2000
"This is the view from the trenches, or in Graves's words from the
'sharp end' ... For friends of military history, Fighting for Canada
... may be one to add to your "want" list."
Bill Bean, Kitchener Record, 14 October
2000
"The grim detail of seven bloody encounters are presented. ......
Fighting for Canada "does succeed in making every battle (if
not every war) comprehensible. ... If you want the details of well
known, but not before well-analyzed, encounters, read this book."
Chris Raible, Beaver, April/May 2001
"The authors -- various military historians -- should be rewarded
for their diligent research and writing skills. Their battle narratives
are compelling without being naive and manage to avoid oversimplification
in the name of meaning."
Michael Johnston, Quill and Quire, June
2000
"This is an excellent work which belongs on the bookshelves of military
history buffs and serious students alike. Every school and military
library should carry a copy. I guarantee it would be well read."
Les Peate, Esprit de Corps Magazine
"Donald Graves has established himself as a premier student of ...
combat narratives. ...... For those interested in detailed studies
of small units in combat this is a primer on how such accounts should
be researched and organized. Christopher Johnson's maps and illustrations
are examples that more operational studies can emulate. ...... Although
the detail is mind-boggling, for those weaned in the "lessons learned"
school of combat analysis, these studies will be great ingredients
for discussions at ... military schools for years to come."
David Skaggs, Journal of Military History
|